If the culprit is always the same, it's the one with the rocket launcher (closest to Marcus' place). If not, well, then it isn't. Not that it really seems to matter, since justice in Sanctuary seems to be served as long as it happens to someone. Evil Tim (talk) 16:47, October 4, 2012 (UTC)
I wonder how can you tell who is the culprit?
Moxxi told me that she shot him 3 times, 2 times her shot was deflected by his shield and the 3rd one "must hurt".
Only one of them had a shield. I accused him but he was not the culprit.
How can anyone tell who is the culprit?
Both times I completed this mission, it was the sniper who did it. The one with the rocket launcher has a shield - but the guy died from a single bullet (and attempting to accuse the guy with the rocket causes the sniper to speak up). So that leaves the one with the pistol (who also has a shield)... but the time I accused him, the sniper spoke up. If you accuse the wrong one, you can quickly accuse the sniper and he'll take the blame as if you accused him initially.
I think the fact that the sniper is not rendering with a shield is a bug. Either way, it doesn't matter which one you accuse, the reward is the same.
Perhaps what Moxxi is trying to tell us is that his shield was blown; the culprit doesn't have a shield. Although in Borderlands 2 logic, that wouldn't make much sense. Also Zed is telling the player the culprit has to much money, and I do believe the Sniper and the rocket launcher are the only blue weapons, but I'm not sure. --Wooning (talk) 07:59, October 8, 2012 (UTC)
2 shots hit the shield, but he still got hurt from the third shot (so, he has a shield. Hover the cursor on them and remember who has a shield bar). The culprit was treated by Zed (so, he has full health). And it was ONE SHOT (it can't be Shotgun and is less likely to be a rocket launcher) Tsukiyomaru0 (talk) 01:51, October 10, 2012 (UTC)
The first time I tried this and went for logic, accusing the one with the shield. The third from the left (from Marcus) spoke up. Since then, I have succesfully accused the third guy about 7 times. Sometimes a rocket launcher, sometimes a sniper, sometimes a shield. Always the third one. Idek. Wolfzoon (talk) 16:32, November 20, 2012 (UTC)