Forum:Jimbo Hodunk Unbeatable

While trying to complete the Zaford-Hodunk clan war, I sided with me Irish brethren but could not beat Jimbo. My cousin and I whittled him down to no health or shield and he lived on for 10 more minutes. We saved and quit and then went back and had the same problem multiple times until we eventually had to side with the Hodunks and killed the Zafords. Is there any way to fix this. I'd like to be able to kill some rednecks in playthrough 2.